Blog Posts

Homemade Uncrustables

I love being able to make a whole bunch of something at one time, freeze it, and then have it available for a quick meal or snack.  These little sandwiches are perfect for that!  Great for packing school lunches, AND for the summer when you are going out (the park, swimming, hiking) and won’t be home for lunch so need to pack one.  Pull these out in the morning, pack them in your lunch and they will stay cold until it is lunch and your kids are ready to eat.  And why uncrustables?  Because kids love that soft fluffy bread in the middle way more than the crust.  And who doesn’t really?

Homemade Uncrustables. Give Smucker's a run for their money!

There are a lot of cool tools to make homemade uncrustables that actually seal the filling inside, but if you don’t have any of those, then you can definitely still make them!

There are a couple different ways to make these.  You can either make 2 small uncrustables per sandwich or one bigger one.  I like to make some of both, because sometimes my kids only want to eat a few bites, and sometimes they eat an entire sandwich.

First you will need 3 ingredients.  Bread, peanut butter and jam.

Bread:  I love homemade bread, and actually never buy commercially made these days.  One of my favorite whole wheat bread recipes is from Jamie Cooks it Up. It makes 5 loaves of delicious light, whole wheat goodness.

Peanut Butter:  We use natural peanut butter, and I usually buy it from Costco.  It only has peanuts and sea salt in it.  But if you want to try making your own, we have a great recipe for it.  Homemade Peanut Butter

Jam:  I make jam every year.  My favorite is strawberry and raspberry freezer jam, but I also make canned jam.  We have some other yummy and healthy jam recipes for you to try:

Beet Berry Jam

Double Berry Jam

All-Fruit Jam

Homemade Uncrustables. Give Smucker's a run for their money!

The SECRET to making these if you are going to freeze them for later, is putting a thin layer of peanut butter on both sides of the bread.  The oil in the peanut butter blocks the moisture and helps prevent the bread from getting soggy.  If you are making 2 smaller uncrustables, then you will spread the peanut butter on almost the entire slice of bread.  If you are just making one, then only put it in the middle.  But make sure you get it on both slices of bread.

Homemade Uncrustables. Give Smucker's a run for their money!

If you are using homemade bread you may want to roll your slices out before you make these so they aren’t quite as thick.  Spread your toppings, and then cut them out!  You can really use anything – a cookie cuttter, a cup, a canning lid.  Then if you want to seal them, press the edges with a fork – or just leave them as is!  Then instead of individually wrapping them, I layer them in between layers of freezer paper, and put them in a tupperware.  They will stay good this way in the freezer for about a month.

Instead of wasting the crusts, use them to make homemade croutons!

Homemade Uncrustables. Give Smucker's a run for their money!

Next time you are in a rush for lunch, pull one of these delights out, add some fruits and veggies and lunch is served!

Homemade Uncrustables. Give Smucker's a run for their money!

Homemade Uncrustables. Give Smucker's a run for their money!

Special Uncrustable Tools

Homemade Uncrustables. Give Smucker's a run for their money!                Homemade Uncrustables. Give Smucker's a run for their money!

Wonder Crust Remover                       Pampered Chef Cut and Seal



What a great idea! So happy to see you are enjoying the bread recipe. It’s one of my favorites as well. Thanks for adding a link back to me.
All the best,


Thanks – such a great idea! What other fillings can you use – my son hates peanut butter!


Yes you could use ham and cheese. The only downside is If you plan on freezing it, ham will produce moisture when it thaws and could make your bread a little soggy.


May be a silly question, but what is freezer paper? Would you be able to keep them frozen longer if they were individually wrapped? Any advice on that? Thanks for the great idea, these will truly come in handy over the summer 🙂


Freeze paper has a wax-like material on one side and then a stiffer type paper on the other side. They would probably stay more fresh longer if you individually wrapped them.


Thanks so much for answering everyone else’s question and not mine. It was greatly appreciated!


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *